17 lines
14 KiB
JSON
17 lines
14 KiB
JSON
{"id":615,"verse_id":"EXO.16.1","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":1,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"1","reference":"16.1","text":"plays an important part in the development of the book’s theme. It is part of the wider section that is the prologue leading up to the covenant at Sinai, a part of which was the obligation of obedience and loyalty (P. W. Ferris, Jr., “The Manna Narrative of Exodus 16:1-10 ,” JETS 18 [1975]: 191-99). The record of the wanderings in the wilderness is selective and not exhaustive. It may have been arranged somewhat topically for instructional reasons. U. Cassuto describes this section of the book as a didactic anthology arranged according to association of both context and language ( Exodus , 187). Its themes are: lack of vital necessities, murmuring, proving, and providing. All the wilderness stories reiterate the same motifs. So, later, when Israel arrived in Canaan, they would look back and be reminded that it was Yahweh who brought them all the way, in spite of their rebellions. Because he is their Savior and their Provider, he will demand loyalty from them. In the Manna Narrative there is murmuring over the lack of bread (1-3), the disputation with Moses (4-8), the appearance of the glory and the promise of bread (9-12), the provision (13-22), the instructions for the Sabbath (23-30), and the memorial manna (31-36).","source_note_position":1,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A1/1"}
|
||
{"id":616,"verse_id":"EXO.16.3","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":3,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"3","reference":"16.3","text":"That the complaint leading up to the manna is unjustified can be seen from the record itself. They left Egypt with flocks and herds and very much cattle, and about 45 days later they are complaining that they are without food. Moses reminded them later that they lacked nothing ( Deut 3:7 ; for the whole sermon on this passage, see 8:1-20 ). Moreover, the complaint is absurd because the food of work gangs was far more meager than they recall. The complaint was really against Moses. They crave the eating of meat and of bread and so God will meet that need; he will send bread from heaven and quail as well.","source_note_position":3,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A3/3"}
|
||
{"id":617,"verse_id":"EXO.16.4","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":4,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"4","reference":"16.4","text":"The word “law” here properly means “direction” at this point (S. R. Driver, Exodus , 146), but their obedience here would indicate also whether or not they would be willing to obey when the Law was given at Sinai.","source_note_position":4,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A4/4"}
|
||
{"id":618,"verse_id":"EXO.16.5","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":5,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"2","reference":"16.5","text":"There is a question here concerning the legislation – the people were not told why to gather twice as much on the sixth day. In other words, this instruction seems to presume that they knew about the Sabbath law. That law will be included in this chapter in a number of ways, suggesting to some scholars that this chapter is out of chronological order, placed here for a purpose. Some argue that the manna episode comes after the revelation at Sinai. But it is not necessary to take such a view. God had established the Sabbath in the creation, and if Moses has been expounding the Genesis traditions in his teachings then they would have known about that.","source_note_position":2,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A5/2"}
|
||
{"id":619,"verse_id":"EXO.16.10","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":10,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"2","reference":"16.10","text":"S. R. Driver says, “A brilliant glow of fire…symbolizing Jehovah’s presence, gleamed through the cloud, resting…on the Tent of Meeting. The cloud shrouds the full brilliancy of the glory, which human eye could not behold” ( Exodus , 147-48; see also Ezek 1:28; 3:12, 23; 8:4; 9:3 , et al.). A Hebrew word often translated “behold” or “lo” introduces the surprising sight.","source_note_position":2,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A10/2"}
|
||
{"id":620,"verse_id":"EXO.16.12","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":12,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"2","reference":"16.12","text":"One of the major interpretive difficulties is the comparison between and . In Numbers we find that the giving of the manna was about 24 months after the time (assuming there was a distinct time for this chapter), that it was after the erection of the tabernacle, that Taberah (the Burning) preceded it (not in ), that the people were tired of the manna (not that there was no bread to eat) and so God would send the quail, and that there was a severe tragedy over it. In both the manna and the quail are given on the same day, with no mention of quail on the following days. Contemporary scholarship generally assigns the accounts to two different sources because complete reconciliation seems impossible. Even if we argue that Exodus has a thematic arrangement and “telescopes” some things to make a point, there will still be difficulties in harmonization. Two considerations must be kept in mind: 1) First, they could be separate events entirely. If this is true, then they should be treated separately as valid accounts of things that appeared or occurred during the period of the wanderings. Similar things need not be the same thing. 2) Secondly, strict chronological order is not always maintained in the Bible narratives, especially if it is a didactic section. Perhaps describes the initiation of the giving of manna as God’s provision of bread, and therefore placed in the prologue of the covenant, and is an account of a mood which developed over a period of time in response to the manna. would then be looking back from a different perspective.","source_note_position":2,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A12/2"}
|
||
{"id":621,"verse_id":"EXO.16.12","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":12,"note_index":2,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"5","reference":"16.12","text":"This verse supports the view taken in chap. concerning the verb “to know.” Surely the Israelites by now knew that Yahweh was their God. Yes, they did. But they had not experienced what that meant; they had not received the fulfillment of the promises.","source_note_position":5,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A12/5"}
|
||
{"id":622,"verse_id":"EXO.16.13","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":13,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"1","reference":"16.13","text":"These are migratory birds, said to come up in the spring from Arabia flying north and west, and in the fall returning. They fly with the wind, and so generally alight in the evening, covering the ground. If this is part of the explanation, the divine provision would have had to alter their flight paths to bring them to the Israelites, and bring them in vast numbers.","source_note_position":1,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A13/1"}
|
||
{"id":623,"verse_id":"EXO.16.14","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":14,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"3","reference":"16.14","text":"Translations usually refer to the manna as “bread.” In fact it appears to be more like grain, because it could be ground in hand-mills and made into cakes. The word involved says it is thin, flakelike (if an Arabic etymological connection is correct). What is known about it from the Bible in Exodus is that it was a very small flakelike substance, it would melt when the sun got hot, if left over it bred worms and became foul, it could be ground, baked, and boiled, it was abundant enough for the Israelites to gather an omer a day per person, and they gathered it day by day throughout the wilderness sojourn. says it was like coriander seed with the appearance of bdellium, it tasted like fresh oil, and it fell with the dew. Deut 8:3 says it was unknown to Israel or her ancestors; Psalm 78:24 parallels it with grain. Some scholars compare ancient references to honeydew that came from the heavens. F. S. Bodenheimer (“The Manna of Sinai,” BA 10 [1947]: 2) says that it was a sudden surprise for the nomadic Israelites because it provided what they desired – sweetness. He says that it was a product that came from two insects, making the manna a honeydew excretion from plant lice and scale insects. The excretion hardens and drops to the ground as a sticky solid. He notes that some cicadas are called man in Arabic. This view accounts for some of the things in these passages: the right place, the right time, the right description, and a similar taste. But there are major difficulties: Exodus requires a far greater amount, it could breed worms, it could melt away, it could be baked into bread, it could decay and stink. The suggestion is in no way convincing. Bodenheimer argues that “worms” could mean “ants” that carried them away, but that is contrived – the text could have said ants. The fact that the Bible calls it “bread” creates no problem. לֶחֶם ( lekhem ) is used in a wide range of meanings from bread to all kinds of food including goats ( Judg 13:15-16 ) and honey ( 1 Sam 14:24-28 ). Scripture does not say that manna was the only thing that they ate for the duration. But they did eat it throughout the forty years. It simply must refer to some supernatural provision for them in their diet. Modern suggestions may invite comparison and analysis, but they do not satisfy or explain the text.","source_note_position":3,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A14/3"}
|
||
{"id":624,"verse_id":"EXO.16.15","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":15,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"4","reference":"16.15","text":"B. Jacob ( Exodus , 454-55) suggests that Moses was saying to them, “It is not manna. It is the food Yahweh has given you.” He comes to this conclusion based on the strange popular etymology from the interrogative word, noting that people do not call things “what?”","source_note_position":4,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A15/4"}
|
||
{"id":625,"verse_id":"EXO.16.15","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":15,"note_index":2,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"5","reference":"16.15","text":"For other views see G. Vermès, “‘He Is the Bread’ Targum Neofiti Ex. 16:15 ,” SJLA 8 (1975): 139-46; and G. J. Cowling, “Targum Neofiti Ex. 16:15 ,” AJBA (1974-75): 93-105.","source_note_position":5,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A15/5"}
|
||
{"id":626,"verse_id":"EXO.16.16","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":16,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"4","reference":"16.16","text":"The omer is an amount mentioned only in this chapter, and its size is unknown, except by comparison with the ephah (v. 36 ). A number of recent English versions approximate the omer as “two quarts” (cf. NCV, CEV, NLT); TEV “two litres.”","source_note_position":4,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A16/4"}
|
||
{"id":627,"verse_id":"EXO.16.22","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":22,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"6","reference":"16.22","text":"The meaning here is probably that these leaders, the natural heads of the families in the clans, saw that people were gathering twice as much and they reported this to Moses, perhaps afraid it would stink again (U. Cassuto, Exodus , 197).","source_note_position":6,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A22/6"}
|
||
{"id":628,"verse_id":"EXO.16.29","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":29,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"1","reference":"16.29","text":"Noting the rabbinic teaching that the giving of the Sabbath was a sign of God’s love – it was accomplished through the double portion on the sixth day – B. Jacob says, “God made no request unless He provided the means for its execution” ( Exodus , 461).","source_note_position":1,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A29/1"}
|
||
{"id":629,"verse_id":"EXO.16.31","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":31,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"1","reference":"16.31","text":"The name “house of Israel” is unusual in this context.","source_note_position":1,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A31/1"}
|
||
{"id":630,"verse_id":"EXO.16.34","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"EXO","chapter":16,"verse":34,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"1","reference":"16.34","text":"The “Testimony” is a reference to the Ark of the Covenant; so the pot of manna would be placed before Yahweh in the tabernacle. W. C. Kaiser says that this later instruction came from a time after the tabernacle had been built (see Exod 25:10-22 ; W. C. Kaiser, Jr., “Exodus,” EBC 2:405). This is not a problem since the final part of this chapter had to have been included at the end of the forty years in the desert.","source_note_position":1,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/Exodus%2016%3A34/1"}
|