12 lines
11 KiB
JSON
12 lines
11 KiB
JSON
{"id":8197,"verse_id":"1JN.4.1","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"1JN","chapter":4,"verse":1,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"1","reference":"4.1","text":"1 John 4:1-6 . These verses form one of three units within 1 John that almost all interpreters consider a single unit and do not divide up (the other two are 2:12-14 and 15-17 ). The subject matter is so clearly different from the surrounding context that these clearly constitute separate units of thought. Since the Holy Spirit is not the only spirit active in the world, the author needs to qualify for the recipients how to tell if a spirit comes from God. The “test” is the confession in 4:2 .","source_note_position":1,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/1%20John%204%3A1/1"}
|
||
{"id":8198,"verse_id":"1JN.4.1","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"1JN","chapter":4,"verse":1,"note_index":2,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"3","reference":"4.1","text":"Test the spirits. Since in the second half of the present verse the author mentions “false prophets” who have “gone out into the world,” it appears highly probable that his concept of testing the spirits is drawn from the OT concept of testing a prophet to see whether he is a false prophet or a true one. The procedure for testing a prophet is found in Deut 13:2-6 and 18:15-22 . An OT prophet was to be tested on the basis of (a) whether or not his predictive prophecies came true ( Deut 18:22 ) and (b) whether or not he advocated idolatry ( Deut 13:1-3 ). In the latter case the people of Israel are warned that even if the prophet should perform an authenticating sign or wonder, his truth or falsity is still to be judged on the basis of his claims, that is, whether or not he advocates idolatry. Here in 1 John the idea of “testing the spirits” comes closer to the second OT example of “testing the prophets” mentioned above. According to 1 John 4:2-3 , the spirits are to be tested on the basis of their christological confession: The person motivated by the Spirit of God will confess Jesus as the Christ who has come in the flesh , while the person motivated by the spirit of deceit will not confess Jesus and is therefore not from God. This comes close to the idea expressed by Paul in 1 Cor 12:3 where the person speaking charismatic utterances is also to be judged on the basis of his christological confession: “So I want you to understand that no one speaking by the Spirit of God says, ‘Jesus is cursed,’ and no one can say ‘Jesus is Lord,’ except by the Holy Spirit.”","source_note_position":3,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/1%20John%204%3A1/3"}
|
||
{"id":8199,"verse_id":"1JN.4.4","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"1JN","chapter":4,"verse":4,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"1","reference":"4.4","text":"Them refers to the secessionist opponents, called “false prophets” in 4:1 (compare 2:19 ).","source_note_position":1,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/1%20John%204%3A4/1"}
|
||
{"id":8200,"verse_id":"1JN.4.6","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"1JN","chapter":4,"verse":6,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"3","reference":"4.6","text":"Who or what is the Spirit of truth and the spirit of deceit in 1 John 4:6 ? (1) Some interpreters regard the “spirits” in 4:6 as human spirits. Although 4:1 a is ambiguous and might refer either to human spirits or spiritual beings who influence people, it is clear in the context that (2) the author sees behind the secessionist opponents with their false Christology the spirit of the Antichrist, that is, Satan ( 4:3 b), and behind the true believers of the community to which he is writing, the Spirit of God ( 4:2 ). This is made clear in 4:4 by the reference to the respective spirits as the One who is in you and the one who is in the world .","source_note_position":3,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/1%20John%204%3A6/3"}
|
||
{"id":8201,"verse_id":"1JN.4.9","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"1JN","chapter":4,"verse":9,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"4","reference":"4.9","text":"Although the word translated one and only ( μονογενής , monogenhs ) is often rendered “only begotten,” such a translation is misleading, since in English it appears to express a metaphysical relationship. The word in Greek was used of an only child (a son [ Luke 7:12, 9:38 ] or a daughter [ Luke 8:42 ]). It was also used of something unique (only one of its kind) such as the mythological bird called the Phoenix (1 Clement 25:2). From here it passes easily to a description of Isaac ( Heb 11:17 and Josephus, Ant. 1.13.1 [1.222]) who was not Abraham’s only son, but was one-of-a-kind because he was the child of the promise. Thus the word means “one-of-a-kind” and is reserved for Jesus alone in the Johannine literature of the NT. While all Christians are children of God ( τέκνα θεοῦ , tekna qeou ), Jesus is God’s Son in a unique, one-of-a-kind sense. The word is used in this way in all its uses in the Gospel of John ( 1:14, 18; 3:16, 18 ).","source_note_position":4,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/1%20John%204%3A9/4"}
|
||
{"id":8202,"verse_id":"1JN.4.10","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"1JN","chapter":4,"verse":10,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"3","reference":"4.10","text":"As explained at 2:2 , inherent in the meaning of the word translated atoning sacrifice ( ἱλασμός , Jilasmos ) is the idea of turning away the divine wrath, so that “propitiation” is the closest English equivalent. God’s love for us is expressed in his sending his Son to be the propitiation (the propitiatory sacrifice) for our sins on the cross. This is an indirect way for the author to allude to one of the main points of his controversy with the opponents: the significance for believers’ salvation of Jesus’ earthly life and ministry, including especially his sacrificial death on the cross. The contemporary English “atoning sacrifice” communicates this idea more effectively.","source_note_position":3,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/1%20John%204%3A10/3"}
|
||
{"id":8203,"verse_id":"1JN.4.12","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"1JN","chapter":4,"verse":12,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"1","reference":"4.12","text":"An allusion to John 1:18 .","source_note_position":1,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/1%20John%204%3A12/1"}
|
||
{"id":8204,"verse_id":"1JN.4.13","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"1JN","chapter":4,"verse":13,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"3","reference":"4.13","text":"The genitive of his Spirit here, like the phrase in 3:24 , probably reflects a partitive nuance, so that the author portrays God as ‘apportioning’ his Spirit to individual believers. This leads to the important observation that the author is not particularly interested in emphasizing (1) the ongoing interior witness of the Holy Spirit (which is what the passage is often understood to mean) but is emphasizing (2) the fact that God has given the Spirit to believers, and it is this fact that gives believers assurance of their relationship to God. In other words, it is the fact that the Holy Spirit has been given to believers, rather than the ongoing interior testimony of the Holy Spirit within the believer, which is the primary source of the believer’s assurance.","source_note_position":3,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/1%20John%204%3A13/3"}
|
||
{"id":8205,"verse_id":"1JN.4.18","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"1JN","chapter":4,"verse":18,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"1","reference":"4.18","text":"The entire phrase fear has to do with punishment may be understood in two slightly different ways: (1) “fear has its own punishment” or (2) “fear has to do with [includes] punishment.” These are not far apart, however, and the real key to understanding the expression lies in the meaning of the word “punishment” ( κόλασις , kolasis ). While it may refer to torture or torment (BDAG 555 s.v. 1 ) there are numerous Koine references involving eternal punishment (2 Macc 4:38; T. Reu. 5:5; T. Gad 7:5) and this is also the use in the only other NT reference, Matt 25:46 . In the present context, where the author has mentioned having confidence in the day of judgment ( 4:17 ), it seems virtually certain that eternal punishment (or fear of it) is what is meant here. The (only) alternative to perfected love, which results in confidence at the day of judgment, is fear, which has to do with the punishment one is afraid of receiving at the judgment. As 4:18 b states, “ the one who fears [punishment] has not been perfected in love .” It is often assumed by interpreters that the opposite to perfected love (which casts out fear) is imperfect love (which still has fear and therefore no assurance). This is possible, but it is not likely, because the author nowhere mentions ‘imperfect’ love, and for him the opposite of ‘perfected’ love appears to be not imperfect love but hate (cf. 4:20 ). In other words, in the antithetical (‘either/or’) categories in which the author presents his arguments, one is either a genuine believer, who becomes ‘perfected’ in love as he resides in love and in a mutually indwelling relationship with God (cf. 4:16 b), or one is not a genuine believer at all, but one who (like the opponents) hates his brother, is a liar, and does not know God at all. This individual should well fear judgment and eternal punishment because in the author’s view that is precisely where such a person is headed.","source_note_position":1,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/1%20John%204%3A18/1"}
|
||
{"id":8206,"verse_id":"1JN.4.19","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"1JN","chapter":4,"verse":19,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"1","reference":"4.19","text":"No object is supplied for the verb love (the author with his propensity for obscurity has left it to the readers to supply the object). The obvious objects that could be supplied from the context are either God himself or other believers (the brethren). It may well be that the author has both in mind at this point; the statement is general enough to cover both alternatives, although the following verse puts more emphasis on love for the brethren.","source_note_position":1,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/1%20John%204%3A19/1"}
|
||
{"id":8207,"verse_id":"1JN.4.20","translation_id":"net-engnet","book_id":"1JN","chapter":4,"verse":20,"note_index":1,"note_type":"study_note","label":"NET study note","caller":"5","reference":"4.20","text":"In 4:20 the author again describes the opponents, who claim to love God. Their failure to show love for their fellow Christians proves their claim to know God to be false: The one who does not love his fellow Christian whom he has seen cannot love God whom he has not seen .","source_note_position":5,"source_url":"https://netbible.org/resource/netNote/1%20John%204%3A20/5"}
|